Article

Can AI replace Teachers? Comparing AI and Human Teachers’ ratings and feedback on students’ essays

2026-06-25

Abstract excerpt

<title>Abstract</title> <p>This study aimed to evaluate the consistency between human and AI-generated ratings on ESL student essays and to compare the manner and focus of their feedback. Using a standardized rubric, three human raters and three AI tools assessed essays based on content, organization, language, and mechanics. Findings revealed that while the average ratings from both groups were generally compara...

Topics

Open a Topic to create a Post that cites this publication.

Uncategorized literature

Identifiers and source

Literature Corpus work: 29d53d4b-19f8-5afa-ac92-8bb8aee91f39
DOI: 10.21203/rs.3.rs-10135718/v1

Open publication

Related research

Semantic proximity does not establish scientific evidence.

Click a neighbor to travelStep 1 · 12 closest

Can AI replace Teachers? Comparing AI and Human Teachers’ ratings and feedback on students’ essaysDOI 10.21203/rs.3.rs-10135718/v1Read

Beyond Automated Scoring: An Evidence-Informed Human–GenAI Complementarity Framework for Formative Writing AssessmentSemantic proximity Read

Teachers’ Views on the Integration of Artificial Intelligence in Assessing and Providing Feedback on EFL Academic Writing in AzerbaijanSemantic proximity Read

A Human-AI Integrated Rating System for Improving Second Language Writing:The Case of Japanese Learners of English for General Academic PurposesSemantic proximity Read

Passing the Turing Test: Fine-tuned AI feedback is less detectable than human or prompt-engineered feedbackSemantic proximity Read

Using ChatGPT-4 to Check Assignments and Provide Feedback; A Mixed Methods StudySemantic proximity Read

A Systematic Comparative Review of Generative AI vs. Teacher Feedback in EFL Writing: Learner Perceptions, Preferences, and Psychological FactorsSemantic proximity Read

Can ChatGPT Replace the Teacher in Assessment? A Review of Research on the Use of Large Language Models in Grading and Providing FeedbackSemantic proximity Read

MultiLLM – Self Reflect Iterative Prompt Methodology based Automated Essay Scoring SystemSemantic proximity Read

Natural Language Processing and Generative AI in the Automated Scoring and Feedback of Reflective Writing in Medical Education: A Validity and Fairness AnalysisSemantic proximity Read

Generative AI in Assessment: AI Detectors and Implications for PracticeSemantic proximity Read

Compassionate Feedback in AI-Assisted Assessment: A Comparative Analysis of Novice and Experienced Teachers' Feedback Patterns within the Integrated AI Triad (IAT) FrameworkSemantic proximity Read

Students’ psychological biases towards teacher and AI-generated feedback: An experiment studySemantic proximity Read